American heart-throbs: Love Index names our 37 favorite vehicles of 2016

It’s all about love.

Thirty-seven vehicles that have captured the hearts of their drivers.

The most-loved brands? Subaru, Ford, Chevrolet and Toyota, each of which garnered multiple Most Loved Vehicle Awards based on the Strategic Vision Customer Love Index (CLI).

The 2016 awards also recognized the best mass-market brand (MINI), best brand under $26,000 (smart), best luxury brand (Porsche) and best full-line corporation (Volkswagen Group of America), plus millennials’ top five mass-market and luxury vehicles.


Subaru, BMW, Nissan, Mercedes and Jeep all scored on both the overall list and the millennials list, with Subaru and BMW capturing five awards each.

Commenting on the millennials rising influence in the automotive market, Strategic Vision seemed to capture the essence of the awards generally by suggesting that “nothing can replace all of the rational and emotional benefits that come from owning a new vehicle.”

The CLI measures “the amount of love owners experience with their new vehicle” by compiling data from more than 120 different aspects of the ownership experience, from interior door handles to taillight design to performance, on a seven-point scale that ranges from “I love it” to “I hate it.”

Strategic Vision, a research and consulting firm, based the CLI on results from its New Vehicle Experience Study, which surveyed 38,763 new-vehicle buyers after the first 90 days of ownership.

The highest-scoring vehicles were the Tesla Model S, which captured overall best model, with 652 points, followed by the Chevrolet Corvette, premium coupe, 582; Mercedes S-Class Sedan, luxury car, 574; Dodge Challenger, specialty coupe, 567; Mercedes GLE-Class Coupe, luxury crossover, 546; Ford Mustang, standard convertible, 517; Audi A5 Cabriolet, premium convertible/roadster, 516; Lincoln MKZ Hybrid, near-luxury APT car, 511, and BMW 3-Series Sedan, near-luxury car, 510.

Other winners included:

  • Subaru WRX midsize car, Outback midsize multi-function car, Crosstrek entry crossover and millennial top-five mass-market pick, and Legacy, a millennial top-five mass-market pick.
  • BMW near-luxury utility X4 and 3-Series Sedan near-luxury car on the overall list, and three on the list of millennials’ top-five luxury vehicles, BMW 3-Series Sedan, BMW X1 and BMW X5.
  • Ford C-MAX Energi small APT car, Mustang standard convertible and F-150 full-size pickup; Chevrolet Volt midsize APT car, Corvette premium coupe and Tahoe full-size utility; Dodge Charger and Challenger, full-size and specialty coupe, respectively, and Durango midsize SUV; Toyota Tacoma standard pickup, Highlander Hybrid APT utility vehicle and Sienna minivan.
  • Nissan Titan XD heavy-duty pickup, Jeep Wrangler Unlimited entry CUV, Kia Sorento midsize CUV, Land Rover Range Rover luxury SUV and Mercedes GLE-Class Coupe luxury CUV.

Karl Miller, Strategic Vision marketing director, described Subaru’s key to success:

“Subaru began to attach its product to the core of who people are and what they aspire to be, and stayed on message for several years. They understood that love is more important than cell phones.”

These cars apparently are the heartbeat of America.

More Like This

Inside story reveals Wards’ best SUV, car interiors for 2020
August 26, 2020

Inside story reveals Wards’ best SUV, car interiors for 2020

How user-friendly is your vehicle? It’s a question asked annually by WardsAuto which results in two separate awards lists, Best Interior and Best User Experience, based on evaluations by WA judges. The inside story of Wards’ Best Interior and Best…

Going places: How the Interstate has paved the way for American drivers
July 25, 2016

Going places: How the Interstate has paved the way for American drivers

The Interstate. Two words that require almost no explanation. Officially the Dwight D. Eisenhower National System of Interstate and Defense Highways, the nearly 48,000-mile, limited-access system has defined long-distance highway travel in America. Now it’s 60 years old. And showing…

Holiday movies at a theater near you
November 24, 2014

Holiday movies at a theater near you

Going to the movies is almost as much a part of the holiday season as road trips, family visits, turkey, presents and noisemakers. It’s what there is to do rather than hang around the house after the main event is…