Where to find dependable used cars the next time you’re shopping

Finding a dependable used vehicle isn’t as difficult as tracking down a unicorn or Bigfoot or a chupacabra.

But sometimes it might seem that way.

Especially if dependable used cars are something you look for only once every few years.

Take this year, 2019, for example …

J.D. Power’s annual U.S. Vehicle Dependability Study (VDS) recently named the most dependable three-year-old cars (2016) in 20 categories, with the Porsche 911 named most dependable overall.

Porsche 911 - dependable used cars
Photo credit: Porsche via NewspressUSA
J.D. Power rated the Porsche 911 most dependable overall.

The dependable used cars that led the 20 categories ranged from the compact sporty MINI Cooper Hardtop to the large heavy-duty Chevrolet Silverado 3500HD pickup and from the Chrysler Town & Country minivan to the Kia Soul compact multi-purpose vehicle.

The ratings of the 20 most-dependable used cars, which were based on responses from more than 33,000 verified owners, focused on the type and number of problems owners experienced during the preceding 12 months, according to JDP, a consumer data and analytics company.

Here are the winners on a list led by Chevrolet in three vehicle segments and Toyota, Lexus, Buick and BMW in two each with awards spread among 14 brands:


Toyota Camry
Photo credit: Toyota via NewspressUSA
The 2016 Toyota Camry won for midsize cars.

Small – Chevrolet Sonic

Compact – Buick Verano

Compact sporty – MINI Cooper Hardtop

Midsize – Toyota Camry

Midsize sporty – Dodge Challenger

Compact premium – Lexus ES 300h

Midsize premium – BMW 5 Series

Large – Buick LaCrosse


Chevrolet Equinox
Photo credit: Chevrolet via NewspressUSA
Chevrolet Equinox was the winning compact SUV.

Small – Volkswagen Tiguan

Compact – Chevrolet Equinox

Midsize – Hyundai Santa Fe

Small premium – Audi Q3

Compact premium – BMW X3

Midsize premium – Lexus GX 460

Large – Ford Expedition


Midsize – Nissan Frontier

Large light duty – Toyota Tundra 4WD

Large heavy duty – Chevrolet Silverado 3500HD


Kia Soul
Photo credit: Kia via NewspressUSA
The 2016 Kia Soul was named top compact multi-purpose vehicle.

Minivan – Chrysler Town & Country

Compact multi-purpose vehicle – Kia Soul

A total of 52 vehicles were named by JDP among the top models in the 20 segments.

The research company scores the top models in each category in addition to the award winner based on mechanical systems, exterior and interior, features and controls, and overall.

For example, although the Chevrolet Sonic was named the award winner, with 35 of a possible 40 points in the small car category, the Hyundai Accent and Nissan Versa also scored 35 points. In the compact SUV category won by the Chevrolet Equinox with a perfect 40, The GMC Terrain finished second with 37.

And so on for the other 18 categories of dependable used vehicles.

But JDP research doesn’t end there for used-car shoppers.

Those looking for older vehicle models can scan easily accessible JDP ratings lists as far back as 2003 (models from 2000) that include not just the segment winners but complete rankings. That’s nearly 20 years’ worth of used vehicles that have gotten past a large portion of their depreciation.

Shoppers will have to look a little harder for older vehicles, but JDP has done the study for 30 years. If that doesn’t cover your used-car search, well, perhaps you are seeking a unicorn.

More Like This

Top Safety Picks for 2017 named by highway safety group
December 23, 2016

Top Safety Picks for 2017 named by highway safety group

There are Top Safety Picks. And then there are Top Safety Pick+ awardees, according to test results from the Insurance Institute of Highway Safety (IIHS). AND THEN, there are Top Safety Pick+ awardees with really good headlights. Only seven vehicles…

Do your homework before shopping for a new car or truck
March 6, 2013

Do your homework before shopping for a new car or truck

Going car or truck shopping without doing your homework is like, well, taking a team into the big game without a plan. It’s like driving across the country without a map – or GPS device. We were reminded of this…