Start your used-car search here when reliability is important


It’s the thing most used-car shoppers rank high on their list of attributes for their next vehicle. After all, who wants to get stuck fixing somebody else’s problem?

But finding a quality, reliable used vehicle may be easier said than done.

A good place to start your search is the Long-Term Quality Index, an ongoing measure of manufacturer and model reliability compiled by used-car expert Steven Lang and statistician Nick Lariviere.

Although even Lang concedes that “the driving and maintenance habits of the prior owner will have a far greater effect on a used car’s longevity that the brand.”

Toyota fares well in the Long-Term Quality Index, a measure of reliability.
Toyota fares well in the Long-Term Quality Index, a measure of reliability.

Still, the index, which comprises 20 years of data on almost a million used vehicles from all over the United States, according to Lang and Lariviere, is “designed to give the average car buyer a picture of what the long-term reliability of different makes and models based on real-world used-car data.”

Thirty-five manufacturers – including several that are defunct, such as Pontiac and Saturn – are represented by between two models (Hummer) and 35 (Mercedes-Benz). Reliability scores are reported on a scale of 0-100 with 100 being the highest possible. That top score is so difficult to achieve that only one vehicle, the Toyota Land Cruiser, receives it among more than 270 rated models, while just seven other models score 90-plus points and 18 more from 80 to 89 points.

The top manufacturers, based on the proportion of total vehicle models scoring above 50 index points, are Pontiac (14/14), Lexus (8/8), Scion and Porsche (4/4) and Hummer (2/2). Ironically, General Motors has ceased production of the Pontiac brand, while Toyota is absorbing its Scion brand.

Other manufacturers getting very high marks are Mercedes-Benz, 97 percent (34/35), Toyota, 95 percent (18/19), Infiniti, 91.5 percent (11/12) and Honda, 91 percent (10/11).

The manufacturers with the greatest number of models in the 90-plus range are Toyota with four – the Land Cruiser, 4Runner, Sequoia and Avalon – plus eight more in the 80-89 index range. Toyota’s luxury brand, Lexus, landed three models in the 90-plus range – the LX, GX and LS. Ford was the highest-rated U.S.-based manufacturer with one 90-plus vehicle (E250) and two 80-89 rated (Excursion and E350), while Chevrolet landed three models in the 80-89 range, including the Suburban, Tahoe and C/K pickup.

Other manufacturers that top out with 80-89 index points are Honda (Ridgeline and CR-V), Dodge (Sprinter), GMC (Sierra) and Infiniti (QX4).

The LTQI study takes into account engine, transmission and powertrain issues, as well as mileage range.

“While we aim to provide objective analysis, we also understand there is no absolute method to predict a vehicle’s quality level with certainty,” wrote Lang and Lariviere on the LTQI website.

“The aim of [the study] isn’t to say ‘you should buy vehicle X, and not vehicle Y,’ but rather to provide an objective way to compare different vehicles based on reliability data collected from trade-in vehicles. … We’re able to give a general picture of what the ‘average’ vehicles for a specific model will look like.”

And that’s as good a place as any to start – and better than most.

More Like This

Car buying by women driven by different reasons than men
November 11, 2014

Car buying by women driven by different reasons than men

The gender gap is alive and, well, kicking tires. That’s the inference drawn from the results of a recent market intelligence study involving about 40,000 U.S. adults by Kelley Blue Book, which analyzed data from its own website and additional…