Ride-hailing services (Uber, Lyft) costly alternative to owning a car

Uber and Lyft ride-hailing services probably won’t replace personal car ownership any time soon.

And the reason is simple.

Replacing your personal car with ride-hailing services would more than double your yearly transportation costs on average in the 20 U.S. cities studied by AAA.

Ride-hailing services

The average cost of ride-hailing (plus renting a vehicle for longer trips) would be $20,118, while the national average cost for car ownership is $10,049, according to AAA.

Relying on ride-hailing would be most expensive in Boston, MA; Nashville, TN, and Seattle, WA.

The AAA report, Cost of Ride-Hailing in Urban Areas, used car ownership costs based on about 11,000 miles of driving annually, the average for city dwellers.

“For those who travel a very limited number of miles annually, or have mobility issues that prevent them from driving a personal vehicle, ride-hailing can be a viable and important option,” said AAA’s John Nielsen. “But for everyone else, the car is still king.”

Ride-hailing costs*

Boston, MA, $27,545

Nashville, TN, $26,397

Seattle, WA, $23,951

Philadelphia, PA, $23,201

Chicago, IL, $22,020

San Francisco, CA, $21,972

New York, NY, $21,279

Washington, DC, $21,093

Denver, CO, $20,434

Cleveland, OH, $20,091

Baltimore, MD, $19,917

Austin, TX, $19,821

Pittsburgh, PA, $18,940

Salt Lake City, UT, $18,866

Los Angeles, CA, $17,951

Atlanta, GA, $17,741

Phoenix, AZ, $17,436

Miami, FL, $17,339

San Diego, CA, $17,316

Dallas, TX, $16,944

* Cost per year, based on 10,841 miles traveled.

Besides all the typical costs of car ownership – depreciation, fuel, maintenance, repair, financing, insurance, license, registration costs and taxes – AAA factored parking expenses into its calculations, “understanding that parking costs can be a major ownership expense for those living in urban areas.”

But even in New York City, for example, where the annual cost of parking is about $8,100, you could own the most-expensive type of vehicle – a pickup truck with $10,054 in annual operating costs, according to AAA’s 2017 Your Driving Costs report – and still spend about $3,000 less than you would to use ride-hailing services for all your transportation needs. Of course, if you drove a small sedan ($6,354 annual operating costs), you would save another $3,700, even in New York City.

Phoenix vehicle owners, on the other hand, spend an average of only about $700 a year for parking. That means operating the pickup would cost about $6,500 less than using ride-hailing services as a full-time replacement, even though Phoenix is one of the least-expensive ride-sharing cities studied by AAA.

AAA focused its study on urban areas because that is where ride-hailing services are most likely to be available as a practical full-time option for local travel.

More Like This

Number of light vehicles on our roads ‘highest in history’

Number of light vehicles on our roads ‘highest in history’

Streets and highways seem more crowded than ever? It’s not your imagination. Almost 253 million light vehicles are operating in the United States, reports IHS Automotive research firm. That’s the “highest in [IHS] recorded history,” according to Richard Read at…

Don’t get me wrong: Driving in Scotland might be fun

Don’t get me wrong: Driving in Scotland might be fun

Bagpipes. Tartan kilts. Golf. Maybe the movie “Braveheart” or TV series “Outlander.” These likely are among the first things that come to mind when most people think about Scotland, the little country north of England with the unicorn as its…

12 steps to preparing for your holiday-season road trip

12 steps to preparing for your holiday-season road trip

Road trips are as much a part of holiday activities for millions of Americans as turkey and presents – and in some places, making snowmen and sledding. But preparing for a holiday-season road trip can make a big difference in…