What you want most from your new car – and how to get it

Quality AND value.

Two things most of us want in our vehicles.

That’s true whether we’re shopping for a new or pre-owned car, truck, SUV or minivan.

Still, it’s not always easy to find those qualities, especially if you’re doing the homework yourself. Fortunately, we can point you in a direction that could help you find the right vehicle.

SC-BLOG_70223-11 (030317 SC What You Want Most From Your New Car – and How To Get It)_WP
The Prius Hybrid helped Toyota to best overall results for 2017.

We’ll start with 60 new vehicles identified by U.S. News – three places deep in 20 different categories – ranging from compact cars and hybrids to SUVs and minivans expected to deliver quality and value now and over the long haul based on five-year total cost of ownership data.

Although, if a pre-owned vehicle is more your financial speed, you might want to consult U.S. News rankings from 2012-16 to get yourself headed toward “an outstanding ownership experience.”

The overall winner for 2017: Toyota, which secured 12 top-three positions out of 60, including two category winners for best hybrid car (Prius) and best hybrid SUV (RAV4).

Toyota’s luxury brand, Lexus, was second with seven top-threes, including three category winners for luxury midsize car (ES), luxury two-row SUV (RX 350) and luxury compact SUV (NX). Ford, Honda and Kia each scored five positions, Chevrolet four, and Acura and Hyundai, three each.

Lexus and Honda tied for most category wins with three, followed by Toyota, Ford, Kia and Chevrolet with two each. Other category-winning brands were Acura, Hyundai, Audi, Nissan, FIAT and Chrysler.

Categories, winners and runners-up are:

The Soul helped propel Kia to a strong showing.
The Soul helped propel Kia to a strong showing.


Compact – Kia Soul, winner, plus Mazda Mazda3, Kia Forte

Hybrid – Toyota Prius, plus Toyota Camry Hybrid, Ford Fusion Hybrid

Large – Chevrolet Impala, plus Toyota Avalon, Nissan Maxima

Luxury midsize – Lexus ES, plus Lexus ES Hybrid, Acura TLX

Luxury small – Audi A4, plus Audi A3, BMW 2-Series

Midsize – Hyundai Sonata, plus Toyota Camry, Camry Hybrid

Sports – FIAT 124 Spider, plus Subaru BRZ, Toyota 86

Subcompact – Honda Fit, plus Hyundai Accent, Kia Rio

The Acura MDX scored in the three-row luxury SUV category.
The Acura MDX scored in the three-row luxury SUV category.


Three-row – Kia Sorento, winner, plus Toyota Highlander, Honda Pilot

Two-row – Nissan Murano, plus Ford Edge, Jeep Grand Cherokee

Compact – Honda CR-V, plus Hyundai Tucson, Ford Escape

Hybrid – Toyota RAV4 Hybrid, plus Lexus NX Hybrid, Toyota Highlander Hybrid

Large – Ford Expedition, plus Chevrolet Tahoe, Toyota Sequoia

Luxury two-row – Lexus RX 350, plus Lincoln MKX, Lexus RX Hybrid

Luxury three-row – Acura MDX, plus Infiniti QX60, Volvo XC90

Luxury compact – Lexus NX, plus Lexus NX Hybrid, Acura RDX

Subcompact – Honda HR-V, plus Mazda CX-3, Jeep Renegade

Minivan – Chrysler Pacifica, plus Toyota Sienna, Kia Sedona

The Chevrolet Colorado made its mark in the compact pickup category.
The Chevrolet Colorado made its mark in the compact pickup category.


Compact – Chevrolet Colorado, winner, plus Honda Ridgeline, Toyota Tacoma

Full size – Ford F-150, plus Ram 1500, Chevrolet Silverado 1500

Of course, there’s more to picking your next vehicle than selecting from a list.

To that end, U.S. News provides a lot more detail in reviews of individual models, including scorecards that comprise critics’ ratings, performance, interior, safety and reliability, as well as prices, pros and cons to purchasing a particular model, and comparisons with other, similar vehicles.

Next week, we’ll take a look at vehicles from 2016 and earlier that made U.S. News rankings and should be available now as pre-owned cars, trucks, SUVs and minivans.

It’s like getting help with your homework without the risk of being caught.

More Like This

Man leaning against car at dusk
December 6, 2019

How to buy a car now … you can get there if you start here

Shopping for a vehicle can be exciting, especially during the holiday season. But it’s almost never easy. There are a lot of things to consider before your purchase to ensure the vehicle – new or used – meets your day-to-day…

RoadLoans: How to get the best deal on a new or used car
February 25, 2013

RoadLoans: How to get the best deal on a new or used car

Buying a new or used vehicle – car, SUV, crossover, pickup – can be a challenging, even a daunting task. Especially if it’s your first purchase. And you don’t have money to burn. You’ll find no shortage of advice on…

Saving money on your next car purchase
January 3, 2013

Saving money on your next car purchase

Going car shopping? You’ll probably think about new vehicles – it’s a fun idea – but if you are like most prospective purchasers, you will get a used one. “The average used car costs less than half the average new…