Dig a little deeper than best-buy awards for possible used-car winners

It’s awards season.

The time of year many websites and publications name their best cars of the year.

The Car Connection and Kelley Blue Book, for example, separately named the Honda Accord midsize sedan their top model from among seven and 12 nominees, respectively. The Car Connection went a bit further and named its top picks in 15 categories.

That’s all well and good, but most Americans purchase used vehicles, not new ones, from franchise dealerships, independent dealers and individual sellers.

So digging a little deeper can really make the most of best-car lists for used-car shoppers.

Subaru Legacy was The Car Connection winner for 2015.

Besides naming its best cars to buy for 2018, The Car Connection (TCC) provides lists of winners from 2011 to 2017, based on the same 10-point ratings scale used for the latest list. That means shoppers can see which award-worthy, now-used vehicles may suit their needs.

Say a shopper is interested in identifying soon-to-be, eight-year-old models to consider.

TCC’s choice for the best car to buy in 2011 was the Hyundai Sonata, which rated 8.6 of 10 points. The other four nominees for that year and their expert ratings were the Infiniti M37 (9 points), BMW 5-Series (8.8), Kia Optima (8.6) and Acura TSX (8.2). Ratings comprise expert scores given to each vehicle across categories including safety, comfort and utility, fuel economy, performance and styling.

That Sonata, which carried an original manufacturer’s suggested retail price (MSRP) of $28,450, now is available with just over 100,000 miles for under $10,000, according to CARFAX.

A similar comparison could be made for best-car-to-buy winners from 2012 to 2017.

Here are examples of what that could look like:

2012 – Ford Focus (8.8 points), $16,500 MSRP, now under $7,000 (95,000 miles), 26 other nominees

2013 – Ford Fusion (9), $21,900, now $11,000 (74,000 miles), 17 nominees

2014 – Subaru Forester (8.4), $22,000, now $10,000 (77,000 miles), 15 nominees

2015 – Subaru Legacy (8.8), $21,700, now $15,700 (30,600 miles), 11 nominees

2016 – Honda Pilot (8.8), $30,300, now about $29,000 (24,000 miles), 13 nominees

2017 – Chrysler Pacifica (8.3), $29,000, nine nominees

Not all websites and publications make it that easy, but it’s worth looking for the opportunity to dig deeper whenever the latest new-car lists are announced if you’re a used-car shopper.

Oh, and that 2018 Honda Accord?

It received a 7.8 expert rating from TCC, tied with the Buick Enclave for top score, and a 9.6 rating from Kelley Blue Book, with an MSRP of $23,570.

More Like This

How and where to find end-of-year new and used car deals
November 6, 2020

How and where to find end-of-year new and used car deals

The end of the year is the best time to get a deal on a vehicle. That’s the common wisdom, anyway. COVID-19 and its ripple effects have changed the calculation this year for many shoppers, but one thing that hasn’t…

Uncage the 400-pound gorilla in your search for a used car?
October 19, 2015

Uncage the 400-pound gorilla in your search for a used car?

Automotive News once called CarMax Inc. the 400-pound gorilla of the used-car market. Not much has changed in the year or so since then, despite the launch of used-car-only stores by Sonic and Asbury automotive groups, which, for the time…